If you've watched or read my presentation on Documentation-Driven Development, you may wonder how to put that new methodology into action. A practical example is often better than a long explanation, so let's see ho to apply it to the new Forms sub-framework introduced by symfony 1.1.
Not DDD
In order to use the new sfForm library, you must either read a book (not yet completely written) or dive into the source code and guess how to use it. To my mind, this is pretty much the contrary of what leads to a large adoption.
The Form framework was designed with power in mind, and reaches this goal very well: you can use it to create forms of any level of complexity, including forms embedding other forms, forms with a variable number of fields, forms split into several steps ("wizards"), etc. It is very much object oriented, so everything can be reused or overridden.
But unfortunately, in order to create a simple form, you need to learn a lot more and write a lot more code than what you used to do in symfony 1.1. The current Forms documentation describes the API and justifies its implementation. It goes very much into the details of each part of the sub-framework, and quite early in the learning process. The result - for me, at least - is that the reader feels overwhelmed by the huge amount of classes, features and options, and dismisses the whole sub-framework for being too complex.
"Let's use that new Form stuff for complex forms and keep the current form helpers and YAML validation for everyday forms", I hear. That's a pity, because once you understand how the new Forms sub-framework works and accept its verbosity, there is no good reason to stick with the old system.
An Ideal sfForm Documentation
I think that a piece of documentation is missing. This piece is probably an introduction to the Form sub-framework.
In symfony 1.0, a single chapter of the book was enough to master forms for most use cases. Even if the new form sub-framework is more powerful than the 1.0 one, it should not be more complicated to learn and use in similar cases. So the sfForms introduction should be short, requiring at most one hour to read it.
After reading this documentation, an average developer should be able to use sfForms in 80% of the cases. That includes at least all the features described in the original Forms chapter of the symfony book:
- Displaying a form
- Available form helpers
- Displaying a model-based form
- Dealing with Foreign keys
- Handling a form submission
- Validating a form
- Available validators
- Repopulating a form
- Complex use cases
The target audience would be people knowing some concepts about symfony, but not yet everything. In fact, they should know what the Chapters 1 to 9 of the symfony guide cover, not more. So some advanced concepts should probably be skipped, or explained only after the fundamental usage is clear.
This introduction should not require additional lookup in the Forms book. That means that it should be self-sufficient. It probably also means not including the justifications of the Forms implementation that you can find in the current Forms book. The reasons why the API was designed the way it is should become obvious at the end of the introduction. Expert customization and rare use cases should probably also be left aside.
The symfony 1.0 documentation introduces concepts and features in a certain order, with a precise purpose: not loading too much information into the reader's mind at a time. In a similar fashion, the forms introduction should be a linear piece of documentation, not a set of articles that you can read in any order with hyperlinks everywhere to break the reading flow.
The forms framework is powerful, but the current form book somehow translates that into length, and verbosity. On the contrary, I think the reader should feel exalted: the documentation should put him in a rush to start using the new forms. So the forms introduction should "tell a story", and gently lead the reader to a point where he feels he can grab the steering wheel and drive the car by himself.
API enhancements
The problem is that explaining the current API takes much longer than a single piece of documentation. That's because of the many options available, because of the many objects to learn, and because even the simplest things (like a list of form controls) look complicated (sfWidgetFormSchema).
There is not much choice to overcome this problem. In order to write a short and readable guide to the forms sub-framework, its API must be adapted. That's right, the API must be changed so that the documentation can be made shorter, and more usable. This is one of the principles of the Documentation-Driven Development methodology.
These API enhancements should be completely backward compatible, so that any existing application using the current sfForms implementation can continue to work seamlessly with the modified implementation. In a way, that qualifies the API enhancements as a simplicity layer on top if the existing code. As a side note, the current Forms book still remains indispensable for advanced usage.
Note that the API enhancements don't need to be implemented before the new documentation is published. The implementation comes second, after the documentation. That's another of the DDD principles: explain first, make it work afterwards. After all, project managers write requirements for web applications before they exist, all the time.
Do As I Do, Not As I Say
Some people are getting sick of reading me criticizing parts of the symfony framework. Well, I'm not criticizing: I'm actively improving.
Rethinking sfForms is a good example for a Documentation-Driven Development. To illustrate this methodology, I'm going to rewrite the Chapter 10 of the symfony book for symfony 1.1. That's right, the current Chapter 10, which describes the "old way" of doing forms, can be rewritten in a similar fashion and serve for symfony 1.1.
But since the current API requires too much explanation to be used, I'm going to introduce the necessary API changes to the sfForms library. I'll create and manage forms in a way slightly different from what the current API allows, to make it simpler to use - and to explain.
When the new Chapter 10 is published here in this very blog, this piece of documentation will be of no use since the features it describes won't be implemented yet. But I know that writing documentation is not enough to convince people (yet), so I will Implement the API changes as a second step to the exercise. As I'm not a very good developer, any help will be welcome during that phase (contact me If you want to give me a hand after the documentation is published).
If everything goes well, the implementation of the API changes will be be released as a symfony plugin - maybe called sfSimpleForms. I hope it can lead more developers to adopt the greatest open-source Forms framework around.